[Data-modeling] Proposed changes to Deity properties

Jeff Fry jfry at metaweb.com
Fri Mar 6 00:01:06 UTC 2009


I just noticed a pile of topics that had been mistyped as religions, 
including: Fire, Commerce, Wine, and Spring. Looking at Fire 
<http://www.freebase.com/view/guid/9202a8c04000641f800000000000ece0>I 
couldn't understand why this happened  ...Until I drilled into Vulcan 
<http://www.freebase.com/view/en/vulcan>. Asserting that he is a "Deity 
of" Fire is quite reasonable, and the fact that we expect a Religion 
here isn't obvious.

It seems like we need to (a) give the deity_of property a less ambiguous 
name, and possibly also (b) add a new property to capture things like 
that Vulcan is a fire god -- possibly something like "Sphere(s)" or 
"Domain(s)" with an ECT like "Religious Sphere".

As far as (a) my first inclination is to name the property "Diety Of 
(Religion)". Another option: "Religion(s) That Worship This Deity", 
which follows the grammar of "People of this ethnicity:", "Organizations 
in this sector:", etc...though it's a longer name.

For (b) I'll propose a new property named Sphere with an ECT of 
Religious Sphere. This would enable, say, a view of fire gods across 
religions.

If this sounds good to folks I'll go ahead and make these changes. Thoughts?

Jeff


More information about the Data-modeling mailing list