[Data-modeling] Made-for-TV Movies

[Tim Kientzle]

Sounds like there's confusion between "what something is"  (video  
production?) versus "how it's distributed" (TV, DVD, movie theater,  
streaming video).  Perhaps we need to add /media/video_production to  
hold the information common to all types of video (who was in it, who  
paid for it, who scripted it, who filmed it, who edited it, when it  
was filmed, when it was released, what book it's based on)?


On Apr 29, 2008, at 6:45 PM, Faye Li wrote:
> Hi,
>
> There are about 200 topics in Freebase that are typed as both /film/ 
> film
> and /tv/tv_program, a co-typing that was previously deemed  
> incompatible.
> Bryan Cheung and I looked through a few instances of them, and some  
> are
> clearly mistyped, some are feature-length TV episodes or miniseries
> arguably marketed as movies, while others are made-for-TV movies that
> qualify for both types.
>
> So, does the co-typing of /film/film and /tv/tv_program make sense?  
> Does
> it apply to feature-length TV episodes and miniseries in addition to
> made-for-TV movies, or only some of the above? Should there emerge a  
> new
> type altogether (/film/tv_movie? /tv/tv_movie?) for it?
>
> The problem of cotyping is that the two types, for obvious reasons,  
> have
> overlapping properties: producers, actors, etc. I'm not as concerned
> about having to enter the same data twice as I am about the type
> implication of doing so, where the same actor then gets cotyped as  
> both
> /tv/actor and /film/actor, just for being in a TV movie! Ditto for the
> producer. On the other hand, /tv/tv_program has no director property,
> which is attached to /tv/tv_series_episode, and /film/film has no TV
> channel property that is part of the data about a TV movie. So  
> without a
> new type, both types are needed to capture all the data. And by the  
> way,
> when I say I'm not *as* concerned about having to enter the same data
> twice, I mean I am concerned. ;)
>
> Examples:
> 1) The three-hour miniseries "Battlestar Galactica" that was a pilot  
> to
> the new series, co-typed with the unholy combo of /film/film,
> /tv/tv_program, and tv/tv_series_episode:
> http://freebase.com/view/guid/9202a8c04000641f80000000009aaffd
>
> 2) "Love Comes Softly", a Hallmark Channel movie original starring
> Katherine Heigl, poster child (the movie, not her) for the new TV  
> Movie
> type if there would be one, currently typed as /film/film:
> http://freebase.com/view/en/love_comes_softly
>
> 3) Too many BBC drama series of "Jane Eyre", such as this one, cotyped
> as both /film/film and /tv/tv_program:
> http://freebase.com/view/guid/9202a8c04000641f8000000000c551bf
>
> -- Faye
> _______________________________________________
> Data-modeling mailing list
> Data-modeling at freebase.com
> http://lists.freebase.com/mailman/listinfo/data-modeling